Google AI Overviews Are Eating Your Clicks. Here's What to Do About It

Check your Google Search Console. Find any informational query you ranked well for in 2023 or early 2024. Look at the click-through rate trend from the past 12 months.

Odds are you're seeing a chart that goes down and to the right, while impressions stayed flat or increased. That's not an algorithm penalty. That's Google AI Overviews answering your users' questions before they ever reach your result.

The numbers are now well-documented. According to Ahrefs' December 2025 analysis, the presence of an AI Overview correlates with a 58% lower average click-through rate for the top-ranking page. Seer Interactive's study found organic CTRs dropped from 1.76% to 0.61% on queries where AI Overviews appear — a 65% decline. Zero-click searches increased from 56% to 69% between May 2024 and May 2025.

Rankings unchanged. Traffic in freefall.

There are two responses to this. One is to treat it as a loss and try to optimize around it. The other is to get inside the AI Overview itself — where websites cited within AI Overviews enjoy 35% higher organic CTRs and 91% higher paid CTRs than non-cited results.

The gap between being cited and being ignored is now the most important CTR variable in search.

How Google Decides What Goes Into an AI Overview

Google's AI Overviews are powered by a large language model that synthesizes content from across the web, filtered through Google's own ranking signals. It doesn't just take the top result — but SeoClarity's analysis of 432,000 keywords found that 97% of AI Overviews cite at least one source from the top 20 organic results.

The implication: you probably need to rank on the first page. If you're on page two or three, AI Overview inclusion is very unlikely regardless of how well-structured your content is.

But ranking alone isn't sufficient. The content also needs to be structured in a way AI can extract — direct answers, formatted lists, FAQ sections, schema markup. A poorly structured page at position 3 will often lose out to a well-structured page at position 7.

Three Paths Into AI Overviews

Get into the top 20 organic results. This is the non-negotiable foundation. AI Overviews draw almost exclusively from established, ranking content. Traditional SEO — authoritative content, backlinks, technical health — still matters because it controls which pages are even eligible for AI Overview inclusion.

Add YouTube videos to your content strategy. Moz analysis and Search Engine Journal research have found YouTube featured disproportionately often in AI Overviews, especially for how-to and tutorial queries. A screen recording with clear narration, uploaded with a keyword-rich title, detailed description, and a transcript is enough to compete for AI Overview placement in many categories. YouTube is owned by Google — this is not an accident.

Implement FAQ schema. FAQPage structured data is one of the clearest signals you can send Google's AI system that your page contains discrete Q&A content. Pages with FAQ schema implementation see 20–40% higher click-through rates from rich results, and the citation effect for AI Overviews is consistently documented across multiple schema studies.

What Makes Google AI Overviews Different From Perplexity or ChatGPT

The strategic difference is audience scale and zero-opt-in. Perplexity has millions of users who specifically chose an AI search experience. ChatGPT has hundreds of millions who actively launched a new product. Google AI Overviews appear for users who typed a query into Google — the entire search-using population, with no behavior change required.

That means the stakes on Google AI Overviews are higher than on any other AI platform. A billion monthly searches touch AI Overviews. Being cited there reaches an audience no other AI surface currently matches.

The optimization approach is also different. Google AI Overviews are the most SEO-dependent AI surface. Perplexity will sometimes surface a well-structured post from a low-authority domain. Google AI Overviews almost never will. Your domain authority and ranking signals carry more weight here than in any other AI discovery context.

The Case for Not Giving Up on Ranking

Some marketers have started arguing that traditional SEO is dead because AI Overviews give answers without clicks. That's the wrong framing.

The data shows the opposite: being cited inside an AI Overview is currently one of the most valuable positions in search. Websites cited in AI Overviews see 91% higher paid CTRs than non-cited results on the same queries. The brand impression from appearing in the authoritative AI answer, even without a click, has brand recall value traditional banner ads can't match.

The brands losing in AI Overviews are the ones who rank but aren't cited. The brands winning are those who both rank and have content structured well enough for AI to extract and attribute.

The Integrated Play

The tactics for Google AI Overviews overlap heavily with GEO for other platforms: structured content, schema markup, FAQ sections, external citations, YouTube presence. Build those correctly and you get lift across all AI surfaces simultaneously.

What changes is knowing where you currently stand — which queries you appear in AI Overviews for, which you're missing, and how your AI visibility compares to competitors in your category. That requires data, not guesswork.

---

Try It on Your Own Brand

ShowYourBrand runs 100 prompts across ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, Gemini and Grok, measures how often and how well your brand is cited, gives a GEO score and action plan. Start your audit from €29 →